The oldest pub in London
Hidden London weeds out the pretenders and declares a winner (and it’s probably not one you might be expecting)
When you next see a sign outside a London public house that says something like ‘Established 1598’ it’s worth asking yourself: “In what specific way are they trying to fool me?”
Occasionally the signage doesn’t even refer to the pub, or the building it occupies. It’s the brewery that was established that long ago – and which is probably now part of some global drinks conglomerate.
Even if the sign does relate to the place itself, it’s possible that the building didn’t begin its existence as an alehouse or inn, or at least it can’t be proved to have done. Covent Garden’s Lamb and Flag (originally the Cooper’s Arms) may be at least 50 years younger than the frame of the building it occupies – as its website clearly states, with creditable candour. A more extreme example is provided by the King William in Sipson, near Heathrow – a centenarian pub in a building that may be 500 years old.
Or, most likely, the pub may have been established in (say) 1598, but not in the building to which the sign is now attached. All London pubs claiming to date from the 16th century or earlier have been pulled down and rebuilt at least once since 1600.
You’re less likely to see such claims in the City of London, the oldest part of the capital, because everyone knows the Great Fire of 1666 razed most of the City to the ground. But impostors are commonplace on the City’s fringes. The website of Aldgate’s Hoop and Grapes asserts that the fire “stopped just 50 yards” from the site of inn. Actually it was more like 500 yards. But that fact turns out to be irrelevant. Most authorities reckon the Hoop and Grapes dates from the late 17th century rather than from before the fire, and it probably hasn’t been a drinking establishment for the whole of its existence. Nevertheless it’s a fine old building and is grade II* listed.
The genuinely old Olde Mitre, in Ely Court, is “genuinely old” in the 1772 sense, not the 1546 sense, as proclaimed on the signage outside. And the building was completely remodelled internally in the 1920s. But there’s no point in getting too hung up on remodelling or the entire top 10 below might have to be discarded, including the esteemed George Inn and Olde Cheshire Cheese.
Some of the most misleading miscreants – whether or not they make an ‘Established .…’ claim – are the pubs that look really ancient, like the Dickens Inn, which was created in 1976 in a relocated and ‘restyled’ former warehouse in St Katherine Docks. It’s almost tempting to propose a ‘law’ that states: “The older a pub looks, the newer it probably is.”
Another counterfeiting culprit is the Prospect of Whitby, in Shadwell (or Wapping, if you prefer), where antique fixtures and fittings have been imported from other sites in a (successful) bid to enhance its tourist appeal. But let’s not be too harsh on the Prospect. Most of the present pub was built around 1800 but parts of it – certainly including its stone floor – may date from as early as 1520. If more of the original structure had survived intact it would be the oldest pub in London, by Hidden London’s reckoning.
Several 20th-century pubs in the Holborn area are styled to look much older than they are, though not necessarily with an intent to deceive. The Cittie of Yorke and the Ship Tavern, for example, were both rebuilt in the early 1920s and endowed with ‘antiquified’ interiors.
The biggest liars are the establishments that don’t even stand on the same sites as their ancient namesakes. Admirable though it is as a pub, the Cittie of Yorke has to own up to that sin, as does Clerkenwell’s Jerusalem Tavern, a 1990s creation in a 1720s building with an 1820s wooden shopfront. It’s not the case with the Ship Tavern – despite what it says on Wikipedia – but it most certainly is with the White Hart on Drury Lane, which outrageously professes to have been founded in 1216. The Londonist says: “It’s a dubious claim. The building is only 100 years old, and built on a different plot to the original White Hart. But we like the sentiment.” That last sentence must surely be tongue in cheek.
When in doubt about the true antiquity of a pub’s premises, one of the best places to check is Historic England’s register of listed buildings. In the case of an older building, you can usually find out roughly when it was built – and how much it’s since been altered – by searching the register (or zooming in on the map, to get round some of the indexing flaws in the search system) and reading the list entry. But surprisingly often you’ll discover that some allegedly ancient tavern isn’t listed at all, meaning the building is almost certainly less than 150 years old – and not of much architectural merit either. Hammersmith’s Blue Anchor – ‘Established 1722’ – is an unlisted case in point, though the nearby Dove really is of early to mid-18th century origin, and grade II listed.
Rotherhithe’s Mayflower – ‘Established 1550’ – is an even more notable omission from the Historic England list. There’s an online review of this quaint-looking place that says “you can tell it’s really old from the leaded glass windows” (which are shown in the photo at the top). But it’s nearly all fakery from the mid-1950s and later – making it “alas only a picturesque pastiche” [Pevsner]. To be fair, the building was hit by a Luftwaffe bomb so there was an understandable need for post-war reconstruction – but the Spread Eagle (as the pub was then called) had already been rebuilt early in the 19th century.
So what is the oldest pub in London? Which establishment was built longest ago and hasn’t since been entirely (or almost entirely) rebuilt? After lengthy deliberation and hesitation, Hidden London has accepted the verdict handed down by Dr John Hawkins, which was published on a plain and simple Google Sites page in 2010. Under a set of rationally formulated rules, and based on some solid (though not exhaustive) research, he declares London’s oldest pub to be the Seven Stars, on Carey Street.
The Seven Stars is the winner by some margin too – as the table below shows. Here’s some history from its website:
“The Seven Stars pub was built in 1602 and in all likelihood was built specifically as an alehouse (the evidence has some patches to contend with). Taverns were usually called the Seven Stars to attract Dutch sailors, which referred to the Seven United Provinces of the Netherlands. The area surrounding Carey Street, bounded by the River Fleet to the east and Thames to the south, was popular with Dutch settlers in London – so it appears late-Renaissance marketing was at work here. Prior to its embankment, the Thames was broader (and therefore closer to the Seven Stars) and industry was very much marine based.
“The pub was called ‘The Leg and Seven Stars’ for many years [Hidden London note: probably corrupted from ‘League of/and Seven Stars’], and although an unbroken run of records dating back its entire 400 year history does not exist, information about every business and service in the area is also incomplete. The Great Fire of London fizzled out before reaching Temple Bar, sparing this original pub, but the unseen cost to London of the fire was the widespread destruction of parish records.”
It’s not clear exactly when ‘The Leg and Seven Stars’ became simply ‘The Seven Stars’ but John Diprose, writing in 1868 [in Some Account of the Parish of St Clement Danes], says “The Seven Stars we fear has been denuded by some vulgar person of its leg or league.”
In case you’d like to double-check the building’s bona fides, here’s a link to the Seven Stars’ Historic England list entry. Yes, it contains a few caveats, and details of 19th century remodelling, but you’re unlikely to find a list entry for any other London pub that admits to the distinct possibility of it being as intrinsically and substantially old as this one.
It’s only right to mention that Brandwood and Jephcote’s London Heritage Pubs (CAMRA, 2008) asserts that “the building itself probably dates only from the 1680s.” No supporting evidence is offered for this claim but if it were true the Seven Stars would drop to the middle of the top 10 below.
Either way, if you’re looking for a stereotypical Olde English hostelry interior, you won’t find that at the Seven Stars. Perhaps that’s why it didn’t feature at all in the Londonist’s Best Old London Pubs poll. But if you want a characterful little pub that really could be as old as you can get in London, Hidden London recommends the Seven Stars highly, though it gets a bit crowded with local lawyers at peak times on weekdays.
Hidden London’s top ten oldies:
Based on John Hawkins’ list but with several revisions
|1||The Seven Stars||Carey Street, WC2||1602|
|2||The Olde Wine Shades*||Martin Lane, EC4||1663|
|3||Ye Olde Cheshire Cheese||Fleet Street, EC4||rebuilt 1667|
|4||The Old Bell Tavern||Fleet Street, EC4||rebuilt 1670s|
|5||The George Inn||Borough High Street, SE1||rebuilt 1676 onwards|
|6||The Hoop and Grapes||Aldgate High Street, EC3||probably 1670s or 80s|
|7||The Spaniards Inn||Spaniards Road, NW3||c.1700, licensed 1721|
|8||The Lamb and Flag||Rose Street, WC2||**see note below|
|9||The Grapes||Narrow Street, E14||rebuilt c.1720|
|10||The Guinea||Bruton Place, W1||rebuilt 1720s|